CM Magazine Review - Through Flood and Fire

Reviewed by: Kay Weisman

Through Flood and Fire, the sequel to Full Steam to Canada, finds Dodie Bolton and her family continuing their westward journey to the Barr Colonies of Saskatchewan. Having survived an ocean voyage and cross-country train ride to Saskatoon, the family prepares for the final leg of their journey—a covered wagon trek across the prairies to the tract of land reserved for them. Dad is anxious to file his land claim as soon as possible, but an outbreak of scarlet fever compels Mam to temporarily remain behind nursing the colonists now in quarantine. As greenhorns, the Boltons encounter a full range of prairie hazards: a valley of snakes newly awakened from winter hibernation; flooded rivers that must be crossed; nasty falls that impede Dodie’s mobility; food insecurity; and raging prairie fires that threaten everything in their path. Eventually, the entire family is reunited on their new land, but it’s clear that more struggles lie ahead as they prepare to build a house and farm the land. 

      Although this story is fictionalized, Patton based the Bolton family on the real-life experiences of Barr Colony settler Dorothy Holtby Boan. The writing is smooth, and Patton’s attention to setting and historical details is commendable. As in the earlier book, some of the characters feel a bit stereotypical. Mam, for example, looks down on those she sees as socially inferior, such as Mrs. Sutton (who worked in service before immigrating) and Mr. Parenteau (a Metis settler who rescues the Boltons on numerous occasions). She also seems unable to part with her old world ideas about “lady-like” behavior, despite the harsh realities of her new life. However, Dodie and Lydia continue to evolve as a result of their experiences, with both girls coming to appreciate the many opportunities their new Canadian life offers them. 

      Through Flood and Fire will be popular with historical fiction buffs (particularly Laura Ingalls Wilder’s Little House devotees looking for a Canadian counterpart) and useful for middle grade classrooms studying Canadian history. A concluding volume is in the works.


Kay Weisman works as a youth services librarian at West Vancouver Memorial Library and chairs the Children’s Literature Roundtables of Canada’s Information Book Award.


This article orginally appeared in CM Magazine. You can read the full article here. 

Share this Post: Facebook Twitter Google Plus